Illogical Harry Potter Fan Theories: The Worst and Most Senseless

Hello friends, today we have a new article for you. Today, we will discuss three fan theories about Harry Potter’s Wizarding World that are considered the worst and illogical. Despite their senselessness, these theories gained fame among fans!

1. Fawkes – Horcrux of Dumbledore

The first theory suggests that Fawkes was Dumbledore’s Horcrux. This theory is both irritating and nonsensical. A kind, truthful, and loyal person like Dumbledore would never engage in the shameful task of creating a Horcrux, as it requires the murder of an innocent individual. We all know that Dumbledore can sacrifice himself but cannot harm an innocent. In my view, this theory is the worst.

2. Minerva – A silent Death Eater

The second theory claims that Minerva McGonagall is a Death Eater. According to this theory, Minerva McGonagall is a Death Eater who played a minor role in the Hogwarts battle and pretended to be innocent to conceal her true nature.

Such a theory is beyond comprehension. Whether it’s the Harry Potter series or its characters, both the movies and the books have consistently portrayed Minerva McGonagall as a loyal, strict, and kind-hearted character.

Also Read: Does the Grey School of Wizardry Teach Real Magic?

Dumbledore had complete trust in her, especially when it came to the safety of children, which is why she was appointed Deputy Headmistress. The idea of Minerva McGonagall being a Death Eater is completely baseless.

3. Hagrid – Another Death Eater

The third theory suggests that Hagrid was a Death Eater. Fans went to great lengths to provide evidence for this theory. According to their perspective, Hagrid was associated with Voldemort since childhood and had connections with him. Although Voldemort framed Hagrid for the murder of Moaning Myrtle and expelled him from Hogwarts, he still maintained contact with him.

Related: Make Your Harry Potter Portrait Now For Free

They argue that Hagrid was an undercover agent in the vicinity of Godric’s Hollow. After Voldemort’s body was destroyed, Hagrid was the first to reach Potter’s cottage and rescue, Harry, as he knew about Horcruxes and anticipated Voldemort’s return. However, no matter how many arguments are presented, it is impossible for Hagrid to be a Death Eater.

Firstly, Voldemort had issues with half-blood wizards, and it is highly unlikely that he would have trusted a giant.
Secondly, Professor Dumbledore had more faith in Hagrid than anyone else, even to the extent of risking his own life. If Hagrid were truly a Death Eater, he would have killed Harry in the Potter cottage, where no one knew whether Harry was alive or not. There were ample opportunities for him to harm Harry if he were a Death Eater.

Must Read: 10 Gifts That Will Make Any Potterhead Swoon

Moreover, Hagrid was a true animal lover with a pure soul. He even found dragons to be innocent creatures. It is heartbreaking to suggest that such a compassionate person was a Death Eater.

In conclusion, these theories about Harry Potter’s Wizarding World are not only the worst but also illogical. They undermine the integrity and consistency of the characters and the world created by J.K. Rowling. It is essential to approach fan theories with critical thinking and consider the evidence presented before accepting them as valid.